One of the most common questions librarians and instructors get from students is, "How do I evaluate an article or/and a journal?". Here are some questions you can ask yourself when evaluating an article.
What?
- What is the subject of the article?
- Is it relevant to your research?
- Does it add to the information you've already found or provide a new perspective?
When?
- When was the article published? This is especially important. Are you looking for historical information or the latest information out there?
- Is it recent enough for your research needs?
Why?
- Why was the article written - what is its purpose?
- Do they describe their research methods and cite appropriate sources?
- Is it presenting research, making an argument, or giving an opinion?
Who?
- Who wrote the article?
- What credentials do they have?
- Who is on the editorial board for the journal? What credentials do they have?
Where?
- Which journal published the article?
- Is the journal published by a scholarly organization or academic publisher?
- Where was the research conducted?
- Would research in another country or region be relevant to your research topic?
How?
- How have the authors conducted their research or made their arguments?
- Do they describe their research methods and cite appropriate sources?